PDA

View Full Version : GFX Grand Team Battle - Round One Entries



Fatal.
08-02-2011, 01:00 PM
GFX Grand Team Battle - Round One Entries

Here are the Team's Entries

Team Espada


http://img808.imageshack.us/img808/6646/ragnarokentry.png

http://i988.photobucket.com/albums/af9/_ADD/Tags/gfxbattle2.png
Team Frosted Pixels


http://img16.imageshack.us/img16/8940/grandbattle2.png

http://img842.imageshack.us/img842/9058/knivesentry.png
Team OLD Designer


http://img25.imageshack.us/img25/8968/round1tl.png

http://img842.imageshack.us/img842/1079/tourreal.png
Team "Team"


http://img40.imageshack.us/img40/5807/22071792.png

http://img40.imageshack.us/img40/1538/49124204.png
Team #1 GFX'ers


http://img706.imageshack.us/img706/4350/gfxtb.png

http://img35.imageshack.us/img35/9075/bigggg.png
Team GFX Crew


http://img713.imageshack.us/img713/8508/zmugfxgb.png

http://img812.imageshack.us/img812/6365/gfxgrandbattlegfxcrewbe.png
Team Rage design


http://i52.tinypic.com/rsfzgi.png

http://i55.tinypic.com/2lwn02u.png
Sadly, Team MarbelGFX failed to pass all of their entries so they are disqualified

This Thread will be closed while we judge the entries

Good Luck Participants
and may the GFXing Gods shine upon you all





---------- Post added at 12:00 PM ---------- Previous post was at 10:27 AM ----------

First Judging:


--------------------------------------------------
Team Name: espada
Lighting: 50
Composition: 50
Flow: 80
Typohraphy: 50
Color: 50
Total Score: 5.6

--------------------------------------------------
--------------------------------------------------
Team Name: frosted pixels
Lighting: 90
Composition: 90
Flow: 80
Typohraphy: 60
Color: 95
Total Score: 8.3


--------------------------------------------------
--------------------------------------------------
Team Name: old designer
Lighting: 60
Composition: 70
Flow: 85
Typohraphy: 50
Color: 75
Total Score: 6.8



--------------------------------------------------
--------------------------------------------------
Team Name: team
Lighting: 95
Composition: 95
Flow: 75
Typohraphy: 60
Color: 75
Total Score: 8

--------------------------------------------------
--------------------------------------------------
Team Name: gfxers
Lighting: 90
Composition: 80
Flow: 90
Typohraphy: 60
Color: 95
Total Score: 8.3

--------------------------------------------------
--------------------------------------------------
Team Name: gfx crew
Lighting: 90
Composition: 85
Flow: 95
Typohraphy: 80
Color: 85
Total Score: 8.7


--------------------------------------------------
--------------------------------------------------
Team Name: rage design
Lighting: 75
Composition: 75
Flow: 70
Typohraphy: 60
Color: 85
Total Score: 7.3

Fatal.
09-02-2011, 02:27 AM
Second Judging:


--------------------------------------------------
Team Name: espada
Lighting: 50
Composition: 60
Flow: 60
Typohraphy: 60
Color: 60
Total Score: 5.8


Comments and Suggestions:
First entry has nice effects, though the black lines presented a distraction as it clashed with the flow of the
piece.Depth, however was not evident.

--------------------------------------------------
--------------------------------------------------
Team Name: Frosted Pixels
Lighting: 75
Composition: 75
Flow: 80
Typohraphy: 70
Color: 90
Total Score: 7.8


Comments and Suggestions:
Seems like both entries was composed from the same brush sets, making the two somewhat similar in compo and flow, thus no
variation of techniques was presented.

--------------------------------------------------
--------------------------------------------------
Team Name: Old Designer
Lighting: 75
Composition: 80
Flow: 80
Typohraphy: 50
Color: 90
Total Score: 7.5


Comments and Suggestions:

Same observations with the team above.

--------------------------------------------------
--------------------------------------------------
Team Name: Team
Lighting: 70
Composition: 70
Flow: 70
Typohraphy: 60
Color: 70
Total Score: 6.8


Comments and Suggestions:
First entry rocks, pulling the stats on lighting, flow, depth and composition. My only drawback is the presence of the
butterflies and the color, seemingly making the tag more effeminate. I have nothing against being effeminate in nature,
however i find the butterflies inappropriate for the theme, while the color is acceptable. Those could have worked better
if the render provided was a girl, however that was IMO only :)

--------------------------------------------------
--------------------------------------------------
Team Name: GFXrs
Lighting: 70
Composition: 75
Flow: 65
Typohraphy: 65
Color: 70
Total Score: 6.9


Comments and Suggestions:
Both are good concepts, however compo and flow wise, both need a bit of tweaking. Colors also need work as well as some
misplaced lighting effects on parts that are supposed to be in shadows.

--------------------------------------------------
--------------------------------------------------
Team Name: GFX Crew
Lighting: 80
Composition: 90
Flow: 90
Typohraphy: 75
Color: 90
Total Score: 8.5


Comments and Suggestions:
Loved the text in this piece http://img713.imageshack.us/img713/8508/zmugfxgb.png, sadly the other entry's text pulled it
down. However, the composition of both are superb and i particularly like the palette of the second entry.

--------------------------------------------------
--------------------------------------------------
Team Name: Rage Design
Lighting: 50
Composition: 65
Flow: 60
Typohraphy: 75
Color: 60
Total Score: 6.2


Comments and Suggestions:
Text in this piece http://i52.tinypic.com/rsfzgi.png was well composed, however both entries need to work on flow and
composition.

--------------------------------------------------

---------- Post added 02-09-2011 at 01:27 AM ---------- Previous post was 02-08-2011 at 11:09 PM ----------

Third Judging:


--------------------------------------------------
Team Name: Espada
Lighting: 60
Composition: 70
Flow: 70
Typohraphy: 55
Color: 80
Total Score: 6.7


Comments and Suggestions:
Even though the effects of both pieces were quite nice
the lighting and the compo drastically destroyed the piece
brought out no depth and focus to the focals
--------------------------------------------------
--------------------------------------------------
Team Name: Frosted Pixels
Lighting: 95
Composition: 90
Flow: 85
Typohraphy: 80
Color: 95
Total Score: 8.9


Comments and Suggestions:
good compo and overall balance to the whole piece
whoever made these pieces really planned it out
they both had that "candy-eye" impression
--------------------------------------------------
--------------------------------------------------
Team Name: OLD Designer
Lighting: 80
Composition: 80
Flow: 78
Typohraphy: 75
Color: 78
Total Score: 7.8


Comments and Suggestions:
All of the pieces were quite moderate
every aspect seemed to lack something
--------------------------------------------------
--------------------------------------------------
Team Name: Team
Lighting: 90
Composition: 86
Flow: 83
Typohraphy: 84
Color: 85
Total Score: 8.5


Comments and Suggestions:
both relatively had great concepts
but some aspects countered out each other
that is why I ended going about the scores
--------------------------------------------------
--------------------------------------------------
Team Name: #1 GFXers
Lighting: 80
Composition: 76
Flow: 80
Typohraphy: 76
Color: 70
Total Score: 7.6


Comments and Suggestions:
All of the pieces were quite moderate
every aspect seemed to lack something

--------------------------------------------------
--------------------------------------------------
Team Name: GFX Crew
Lighting: 87
Composition: 90
Flow: 90
Typohraphy: 87
Color: 85
Total Score: 8.7


Comments and Suggestions:
each piece had a different concepts concept
but were wildly a great combination as a pair

--------------------------------------------------
--------------------------------------------------
Team Name: Rage design
Lighting: 80
Composition: 70
Flow: 67
Typohraphy: 70
Color: 60
Total Score: 6.9


Comments and Suggestions:
All of the pieces were quite moderate
every aspect seemed to lack something

--------------------------------------------------

Fatal.
11-02-2011, 10:45 AM
Fourth/Final Judging:

--------------------------------------------------
Team Name: Team Espada
Lighting: 55
Composition: 60
Flow: 60
Typohraphy: 57
Color: 62
Total Score: 5.8


Comments and Suggestions:
Empty white space is just a bad idea. Text doesn't fit well and is unreadable. I would go for having a chaos themed stock as a BG since it has some splatters on it, toned it down and add some gradient maps. Seriously, this needs total redoing of entry.

--------------------------------------------------
--------------------------------------------------
Team Name: Team Frosted Pixels
Lighting: 80
Composition: 76
Flow: 67
Typohraphy: 87
Color: 90
Total Score: 8


Comments and Suggestions:
On a first glance, it really look awesome and fab! But staring at it makes it boring, I can't feel the depth on this, overused of vectorish stuffs and the typo seems bad in a matter of choosing the font to be used. Lighting is amazing!

--------------------------------------------------
--------------------------------------------------
Team Name: Team OLD Designer
Lighting: 86
Composition: 60
Flow: 65
Typohraphy: 56
Color: 60
Total Score: 6.5


Comments and Suggestions:
Same as Team Frosted Pixels, overusing vectorish stuffs is just meaningless, yes it will look great but staring at it makes it boring seriously. Some lightings on the render is badly done, although on their 2nd entry, the "starry" thingy is amazing though it takes out the focus on the main render. Probably lower it a bit or just remove it, and the typo is bad. The "circuit" looking thing that is brushed on the lower right corner of the 2nd entry doesn't fit too, it should be removed!

--------------------------------------------------
--------------------------------------------------
Team Name: Team Team
Lighting: 60
Composition: 59
Flow: 70
Typohraphy: 61
Color: 59
Total Score: 6.1


Comments and Suggestions:
Lighting is just fine although it's almost unseen on their first entry. The "+" thingy should be placed at the back. Typo is badly done and I don't think the font on their 2nd entry is the right one.

--------------------------------------------------
--------------------------------------------------
Team Name: Team #1 GFX'ers
Lighting: 55
Composition: 63
Flow: 67
Typohraphy: 52
Color: 60
Total Score: 5.9


Comments and Suggestions:
This is WOW in a bad way! I mean, the pieces looks low quality specially on their 2nd entry. Typo is bad, and the plain black BG is bad. I would probably use some sort of manipulation of vectorish stuff but minimal usage. They overused the brushes too imo.

--------------------------------------------------
--------------------------------------------------
Team Name: Team GFX Crew
Lighting: 84
Composition: 82
Flow: 76
Typohraphy: 80
Color: 88
Total Score: 8.2


Comments and Suggestions:
This is the one! Clean, smooth looking works, right colors and typos makes it awesome. I would just point out something on the 2nd entry, those vector brushes are used in a bad way imo, probably remove the one on the right side the one with swirls lol and use some minimal effect c4ds. :)

--------------------------------------------------
--------------------------------------------------
Team Name: Team Rage Design
Lighting: 71
Composition: 63
Flow: 56
Typohraphy: 70
Color: 72
Total Score: 6.6


Comments and Suggestions:
There is no flow, it's sort of messy and the typo is bad, but lighting is simple yet effective.

--------------------------------------------------

I'll be Finalizing all the votes and Will announce the 4 Winners of this round